Look at profit after ads, not conversion rate.
A promo can lift conversion and drop CPA and still leave you with fewer dollars than a normal week. Discount depth, gift cost and fees eat it.
A BFCM plan can look fine in a spreadsheet and break on the day, like a purchase event that stops firing at peak. Free calculators for your offer, your payback and your Amazon deals, plus the ten checks to run before you lock it.
Start with what a new customer is worth at the offer price. Then check what the same offer costs you on everyone else this month. Selling on Amazon? Price each deal against the sales you’d get anyway. Then plan the creative to carry the spend.
The CAC each offer can carry once repeat orders come back at full price, and the month you get paid back.
What each offer costs on every order this month, including the returning customers who'd have bought anyway, and the orders you need to stay ahead.
Whether a Prime Day or BFCM deal on one ASIN beats the lift event traffic gives you for free, the deepest discount that still pays, and how much stock to send.
How many concepts, formats and placements your Black Friday budget needs, across video, static and carousel.
Unit economics, paid rules, tracking and 3PL capacity. Each one is a way a plan looks fine on paper and breaks on the day.
A promo can lift conversion and drop CPA and still leave you with fewer dollars than a normal week. Discount depth, gift cost and fees eat it.
Blended MER looks great because your best customers buy on the email and SMS pushes. That hides what paid is really costing you for new customers.
The math falls apart when carts bunch just above a gift threshold, codes stack on auto-applied promos, or the BFCM discount lands on top of subscribe-and-save.
A gift or hero SKU selling out, or orders blowing past your 3PL's daily cap, turns into refunds, chargebacks and paused subscriptions.
Last-minute changes to a lander, cart drawer or subscription widget are the usual reason purchase events stop firing, report pre-discount revenue or double count.
Deep multi-pack deals on consumables pull December and January refills forward, and you get a trough after Cyber Week.
Morning email and SMS sales make blended ROAS look great while the last chunk of prospecting spend quietly loses money.
Tripling Meta spend with a "30% off" sticker on last month's ads drives up frequency and CPMs, and the promo lift fades.
Most paid social traffic lands in an in-app browser on a phone. A page that doesn't match the ad, or a code people have to type in, costs you the sale.
Deal buyers churn faster, and they cancel when a renewal charges right after they bought a 90-day supply.
Pull one clean dataset (last year and the trailing 30 days) so finance, growth and ops work off the same numbers. Then put an owner on every fix before the code freeze.
Upload your past promo cohorts, SKU margins and ad exports, and work through all ten with an operator's prompt pack.
One prompt per check, written to run against your Shopify and Meta exports.
A Claude skill that reads competitors' live Black Friday ads and offers and tells you what they're betting on.
The free Blindspot audit covers checks 1, 2, 5 and 7 against your real accounts: profit after ads, new vs returning, purchase tracking and the numbers your intraday calls will run on. Every finding sized in dollars, read-only, back in 3 to 5 days.
Run the free BFCM auditOne pattern, fully worked, every Thursday. What actually breaks in paid media and measurement at $10M-$100M DTC brands.